Search
Leave a Message
Thank you for your message. I will be in touch with you shortly.
Browse Properties
A quiet winter pond bordered by bare trees, frost-touched grass and a curving woodland walking path.

At Mountain Lakes This Winter, One Stone Bridge Is Back and the Other Is Still Closed

November 12, 2026

"The historic stone arch bridge on the Red Trail is a contributing structure to the state and nationally designated Princeton Ice Company historic site." That sentence comes from a municipal memo by Purcell, quoted by Patch in April 2025 when Princeton Council awarded the contract to rebuild two footbridges at Mountain Lakes Preserve. Nineteen months later, that arch is the one of the two bridges still closed to walkers.

As of the municipality's November 8 construction update, the Green Trail bridge near Mountain Lakes House "has been restored and is open to pedestrians," and the Red Trail Bridge "is temporarily closed." That split decides how the preserve works this winter. The way into Mountain Lakes now runs past the House. At the historic arch, the municipality's updates have moved from stonework to the landscape around it.

The arch is part of the ice farm

The trail map from Friends of Princeton Open Space says that in the 19th century, "until the advent of mechanical refrigeration, a group of man-made lakes were the center of an ice farming operation." The stone arch on the Red Trail is a surviving piece of that operation. It counts toward the historic designation of the Princeton Ice Company site, so it is being rehabilitated as a historic structure.

The memo Patch quoted lists the arch's problems: "varying degrees of erosion at the arched bridge footings, substandard parapets with missing stone, leaning and / or misaligned spandrel walls, and other surficial mortar issues." Both bridges had deteriorated over the years, and both were damaged during Tropical Storm Ida.

The historic status also brought in outside funding. Patch reported a $395,218 matching grant from the New Jersey Historic Trust, of which $316,174.50 was set aside for construction. The total contract with Colonnelli Brothers, Inc. of Hackensack was $947,200. The Green Trail bridge is also stone, and its footings were eroded and undermined during the same storm. The memo noted that "the reconstruction of this bridge is not included in the grant." The two bridges were bid as one project but with different funding, and they have reopened on different schedules.

How 2026 went, one update at a time

Princeton's weekly construction and traffic forecasts have tracked the footbridges all year. Read in order, they show the preserve coming back one crossing at a time.

Municipal update Red Trail bridge Green Trail bridge What the update said
February 22, 2026 Closed Closed Work paused, contractor to return in March
July 12, 2026 Closed Open Green Trail bridge restored
October 18, 2026 Closed Open Capstone installation scheduled on the Red Trail bridge
November 8, 2026 Closed Open Area being prepared for landscape rehabilitation

In late February, the municipality said the work had paused, Colonnelli Brothers would return in March "to continue and complete construction," and both the red and green trail bridges were temporarily closed to pedestrians. Last winter, then, neither crossing was open. This winter one is.

The last two rows of the table show where the Red Trail work stands now. The forecast for the week of October 19 said the contractor "will be installing capstones," the stones that finish the top of a masonry wall or parapet. The November 8 update no longer mentions capstones and says the contractor is "preparing the area for landscape rehabilitation on the Red Trail Bridge." The updates have moved from the masonry the memo described to the ground around the arch, and the bridge remains closed to pedestrians.

The House driveway is now the main way in

Because the reopened bridge is the one near Mountain Lakes House, the trails that start along the House driveway are the easiest to reach this winter. The FOPOS trail map puts several routes there:

  • John Witherspoon Woods Trail, 0.7 mile. Starts at the trailhead kiosk halfway down the driveway to Mountain Lakes House and climbs through hardwood forest with scattered boulders.
  • Boardwalk-Tusculum Trail, 1.0 mile. A raised boardwalk and paths connecting Great Road to Cherry Hill Road, reachable from the same kiosk.
  • West Field Loop, 0.5 mile. Also reachable from the kiosk.
  • James Sayen Trail, 1.2 miles. The wooded trail that circles the lakes. It can be reached from Mountain Lakes House, the Boardwalk-Tusculum Trail and the Stuart-Coventry View Trail.

The James Sayen Trail circles the old ice ponds, which makes it the trail closest to the preserve's history. The map lists Mountain Lakes House as one of its access points, and the restored Green Trail bridge is near the House. Trail kiosks are the best place to check which segments currently run past the closed Red Trail arch.

The map also gives the bigger picture. FOPOS describes the area as having nine miles of hiking trails across 400 acres of protected open space and farmland. One closed bridge leaves a lot of that network open.

Other trailheads into the same woods

Three other trailheads on the FOPOS map start routes away from the House driveway:

  1. The main parking lot, west end. The Stuart-Coventry View Trail runs 0.9 mile northwest along the Coventry Farm boundary, with views of the farm and the lakes.
  2. The main parking lot, east end. The Pettoranello-Brookside Trail runs 1.5 miles. A short Nature Trails loop of 0.5 mile circles the pond and the main lot.
  3. The small lot on Cherry Hill Road. The Stuart-Witherspoon Trail runs 1.1 miles southwest to the Great Road and passes Devil's Cave.

The Community Park North Trail is a 0.3-mile path through pine woods, reached from the Unitarian Church parking lot and the main driveway.

FOPOS maintains most of this land, including the Billy Johnson Mountain Lakes Nature Preserve, Mountain Lakes North and John Witherspoon Woods. The Princeton/Pettoranello Foundation looks after Pettoranello Gardens. So the work on the arch is a municipal construction project inside woods that a nonprofit tends the rest of the year.

New signs, and a coffee stop in the next woods north

On November 2, the municipality announced new park entrance signs that replace older signs in some places and mark "some of Princeton's lesser-known trails." The signs are color-coded by type of park. Green signs with a butterfly and flowers mark smaller active-recreation parks and playgrounds. Brown signs with a green shrub logo mark larger active-recreation parks. Passive-recreation parks get brown signs showing native wildlife found in the area. A preserve like Mountain Lakes falls in the last group.

If the Red Trail closure cuts a Mountain Lakes walk short, Herrontown Woods is the next large tract of woods on the north side of town. Its main parking lot is at 600 Snowden Lane. The kiosk there has trail access and brochures with trail maps, and the Friends of Herrontown Woods also list Autumn Hill Reserve and Barbara Smoyer Park as parking options. The group says Herrontown Woods adjoins the Autumn Hill Reservation and All Saints preserves, and together they make up more than 260 acres of continuous open space.

The next date on that side of town is Sunday, December 6, from 9 to 11 a.m., when May's Café sets up as a pop-up with freshly brewed coffee and homemade treats. It runs at the Botanical Art Garden, known as the Barden, next to the main parking lot at 600 Snowden Lane. Proceeds support stewardship and programming at Herrontown Woods.

A good December Sunday could combine the two. Start the James Sayen loop at Mountain Lakes House, near the Green Trail bridge that was closed last February. Then drive to Snowden Lane for coffee in the Barden before the café closes at 11.

The weekly updates are the place to check on the Red Trail arch. Princeton posts them in its News Flash feed, and the footbridge entry is the line that will change when the bridge reopens.

I keep track of details like these across Princeton, from which trailheads are open to which streets are under construction this week, because they shape daily life in a house as much as its floor plan does. If you're thinking about a Princeton home and want to know what's within walking distance of it, Heidi Hartmann is glad to walk through it with you. Let's Connect.

Follow Us On Instagram